COMMENTS BY SALMON

Exodus

 I am unable to finish this scenario because the combat difficulty is beyond my ability. I lack the intimate knowledge of the combat mechanics and engine to make proper decisions against some ridiculous monsters. Through beta-testing I am aware of the depth of story, and award points solely on the design and story. This scenario is unplayable except by a few tactitians, without resorting to cheating through re-loads, level editing, or scenario editing.

Rating: 7.5

Magus of Cattalon

 I found this to be a very frustrating scenario, but I WANTED to play it and finish it. It was clear what the progression should be, and side adventures were frequently available. This is my favorite of Smoo's adventures and I found it very enjoyable. Some minor tech-glitches did lift me out of the reverie, but weren't enough to frustrate me.

Rating: 8.4

Redwall: Prologue

This scenario is well written, descriptive, and visually appealing. I found it boring as hell because of complete lack of knowledge of the book series upon which it is based. I don't want to read the books, so it failed on that level. I didn't find myself willing to finish it, but that is a failure of the audience, not the author.

Rating: 7.0