REDWALL: PROLOGUE JUDGING
Bain-Ihrno
Most of the graphics were very good. However, the plot wasn't that good. It's only the beginning, and the narration was lame. My main gripe, however, is that the scenario is no fun at all. They're obnoxious and there's nothing fun about them. The ending seems a bit rushed but the final animation was cool. Overall, good technical tricks, below average plot, no fun. I wouldn't recommend it unless you're really bored.
Rating: 5.2
Kelandon
Lovely. The graphics were particularly striking. Having read the books actually makes it better, not worse, which is unusual. The tasks were original but somewhat annoying.
Rating: 7.4
Salmon
This scenario is well written, descriptive, and visually appealing. I found it boring as hell because of complete lack of knowledge of the book series upon which it is based. I don't want to read the books, so it failed on that level. I didn't find myself willing to finish it, but that is a failure of the audience, not the author.
Rating: 7.0
Most of the graphics were very good. However, the plot wasn't that good. It's only the beginning, and the narration was lame. My main gripe, however, is that the scenario is no fun at all. They're obnoxious and there's nothing fun about them. The ending seems a bit rushed but the final animation was cool. Overall, good technical tricks, below average plot, no fun. I wouldn't recommend it unless you're really bored.
Rating: 5.2
Kelandon
Lovely. The graphics were particularly striking. Having read the books actually makes it better, not worse, which is unusual. The tasks were original but somewhat annoying.
Rating: 7.4
Salmon
This scenario is well written, descriptive, and visually appealing. I found it boring as hell because of complete lack of knowledge of the book series upon which it is based. I don't want to read the books, so it failed on that level. I didn't find myself willing to finish it, but that is a failure of the audience, not the author.
Rating: 7.0
DID NOT ADVANCE
TO BEST SCENARIO